Potters Cay Fish Fry

Nestled under the bridge that connects New Providence to Paradise Island is Potters Cay, another location where travelers can experience Fish Fry Bahamas. From freshly caught food to lively fruit markets, the small island is packed to the brim with energy. 

While Arawak Cay may be the more famous Fish Fry Bahamas location, Potters Cay is a favorite among locals and is an area you’ll want to explore. From the freshly caught seafood to the markets, conch shacks, and fishing docks, the tiny island offers plenty to see and do. 

Fish Fry Bahamas at Potters Cay Nassau

Potters Cay Nassau: A History

When Nassau began its transformation into the tourist hub it is today, construction teams dredged the Nassau Harbour so that it could accommodate large boats. These teams then used the sand they excavated to create artificial islands, such as Arawak Cay, another one of the contenders for the top Fish Fry Bahamas location. 

Like its competitor, Potters Cay Nassau is also an artificial island – one that stretches out beneath the bridge connecting New Providence to Paradise Island. The collection of docks that cover the island is home to a special experience: Fish Fry Paradise Island. 

Since the island’s creation, Fish Fry Paradise Island has evolved into a collection of restaurants and markets.

Fish Fry Bahamas: A History 

If you’re unfamiliar with it, Fish Fry Nassau Bahamas is more than just a fried fish. It’s a culinary gathering where vendors operating out of restaurants and stalls cook up fresh and mouth-watering Bahamian food. 

Fish Fry Bahamas features fresh and delicious dishes, like cracked crawfish (lobster).

While nearby Arawak Cay may be the more famous Fish Fry Bahamas location (hence its “Fish Fry” nickname), Potters Cay is a hidden gem. While you might not find many tourists there, you will find locals, which should help convince you that it’s worth a visit. 

What to See and Do

Potters Cay Nassau might not be as big as New Providence or Paradise Island, but it still has plenty of fun things to do, especially around lunchtime. 

The Food 

As you walk around Potters Cay, you’ll find all sorts of venues serving up some of the freshest food around.

Restaurants serve conch in many ways, but conch fritters are one of the most popular variations.

Conch is the national food of the Bahamas and is something you’ll want to try while you’re in the country. At Potters Cay, you can have it fried like calamari, in soups, served raw, and as a salad. You can find around 40 restaurants on the island – all of them serving conch in a different way.

Besides conch, you’ll also want to try fried fish (it is Fish Fry Bahamas, after all) and Bahamian lobster. The latter is a spiny lobster that many people refer to as a crawfish. 

The Markets

In addition to eating, you’ll also want to visit the markets on Fish Fry Paradise Island. You’ll find all sorts of fresh produce on the island, as well as vendors selling conch. 

Getting in

Fish Fry Paradise Island has a central location that makes it easy to reach.

If you’re entering Nassau from the cruise ship port, simply walk east down Bay Street towards the bridge to Paradise Island. The entrance to the island is before the bridge, so if you reach the bridge itself, you’ve gone too far. Look for it down a small side street. 

Fish Fry Bahamas is easy to miss — it’s under the bridge that connects to Paradise Island.

The walk from the area around the cruise port should take between 25-35 minutes. If that’s too long or the sun is too hot, a taxi can have you there in a matter of minutes. 

Depending on where you’re traveling from, you might also want to consider taking a bus, or jitney. These are convenient (provided you know the route) and are more affordable than taxis. They’re cash only, however, so make sure to have small bills on hand.

Getting Around

Once you’re at Potter’s Cay, it’s just a matter of walking around until you find a venue you feel like eating at. You can also visit the fruit and vegetable market and even take home some fresh conch. As with most Nassau markets, be prepared to haggle. 

It’s easy to wander from venue to venue until you find the one you want to eat at.

In the evening, a party atmosphere takes over and it becomes full of locals. Consider visiting if you feel up for an adventure! 

Our Travel Guide Suggests…

Restaurants like Mckenzie’s Fresh Fish & Conch serve up some of the best food on the island.

Don’t let the rustic appearance of Potters Cay turn you off. While it’s a far cry from the luxury dining experience offered at the top Nassau resorts, the food is better and caught that day out of the nearby waters. Plus, a visit lets you experience Fish Fry Bahamas. 

Fish Fry Nassau Bahamas: Enjoy an Authentic Bahamian Experience

Fish Fry Bahamas is a culinary gathering of restaurants, stalls, and shacks that serves up fresh and delicious food. And while you can enjoy the experience at several places throughout the Bahamas, Potters Cay Nassau might just offer the best Fish Fry. 

Given its location, Potters Cay is nestled between a host of other sites. From nearby attractions like Fort Fincastle and Queen’s Staircase to Junkanoo Beach, a quick walk or taxi ride can get you wherever you’re planning to go. 

Looking to learn more about some of the top Nassau attractions? Head over to our interactive travel map, and make sure to browse through some of our other guides before you go.